Serious injuries from traffic collisions 75% higher than Garda figures, researches say

— An average of 100 cyclists hospitalised a year with “clinically serious injuries”.

Serious injuries from road traffic collisions are 75% higher than Garda figures which are used by the Road Safety Authority (RSA) according to research conducted by the authority, the HSE and Trinity College Dublin.

...I'm sorry to disrupt you while you're reading this article, but without messages like this, IrishCycle.com's reader-funded journalism won't survive. With 676k views so-far this year, it's not just "avid cyclists" that this website reaches. But the number of subscribers is around 0.6% of readers. This large gap between readers/subscribers is standard for non-paywall reader-supported journalism, but IrishCycle's journalism needs more support. Don't delay, support monthly or yearly today. Now, back to the article...

The difference between hospital figures and police figures is a known issue internationally which prompted the European Commission to recommend member states to formally report on serious injuries using hospital data.

The number of people admitted to hospital as in-patients who were recorded as being in road traffic collisions between 2014 and 2021 was 15,677 — this compares to ‘serious injuries’ 8,977 recorded in the Garda Síochána statistics.

The data was released today as the RSA Annual Conference started in Dublin this morning.

An RSA press release said: “The discrepancy between hospital and police data has been observed internationally and can be more pronounced when looking at cyclist serious injuries. This was the case in Ireland, following the findings of this research project, where 2.4 times more cyclists were hospitalised following a road traffic collision, compared to numbers recorded in official figures recorded by An Garda Síochána and reported by the RSA.”

However, the RSA did not outline that the discrepancy between people cycling is also internationally known to be because hospital data for cyclists does not distinguish between road traffic collisions and sporting and other off-road injuries.

The RSA added: “For cyclists specifically, this new Irish study noted that 63% of all cyclists hospitalised sustained their injuries in single cyclist collisions, where no other vehicle was involved.”

Generally, the RSA said that there are many reasons why hospital figures are higher than police-reported figures, including if “an incident was not formally reported to police, or if a serious injury only became apparent in the days immediately following a collision.” Of course, the RSA does not say that it also includes injuries where people were fobbed off by Garda officers and the incident was not recorded for that reason.

Junior transport Minister Jack Chambers TD said: “Having an accurate account of the serious injuries that people experience as a result of a road traffic collision is central to road safety. This will inform road safety policy as well as feed into measures to improve post-crash response, infrastructure, and technology.”

He added: “In addition, the implementation of the measures contained in the speed limit review, changes to penalty points legislation, increased enforcement by An Garda Síochána and the RSA’s education and awareness campaigns are all vital to reducing serious injuries and making our roads safer for all users.”

Dr Stefania Castello of the research department at the Road Safety Authority said: “In this study, we also focused on looking at the profile of the cyclists who sustained the most severe injuries from a clinical point of view. We saw that these cyclists were more frequently males, 45 years or older, and sustained serious lower limb or head injuries.”

He added: “This is new information that the RSA has not previously had access to and provides valuable information to us to inform the development of evidence-based interventions for road safety and for public health.”

Table 1. Total number of cyclists recorded by AGS and in hospital data. Of the total of hospitalised cyclists, it is also shown the total of cyclists who sustained clinically serious injuries. (RSA)

CyclistsTotal period 2014-2021
Serious injuries AGS1697
All hospitalised4153
Hospitalised with clinically serious injuries700

4 comments

  1. I was seriously expecting the serious injuries to be higher then the garda numbers not lower. From years of dealing with rtcs I also found a lot of injured parties mainly passengers cyclists and pedestrians didn’t get the gardai involved due to alcohol whereas with drivers they get no choice gardai always are informed of alcohol use might be one of many reasons for distorted figures including lack of faith in reporting incidents

    Reply
      • It says 1697 for garda serious hospital serious only 700 rest were not deemed serious I would love to see what they count as non serious ie cuts simple fractures etc unlike complicated fractures spinal and life alternating injuries which are serious

        Reply

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.